Evolutionary relevance of music
September 5, 2006Aapparently, humans are hard-wired to enjoy music. What is the evidence?
Researchers at the Montreal Neurological Institute, for example, have scanned musicians’ brains and found that the “chills” that they feel when they hear stirring passages of music result from activity in the same parts of the brain stimulated by food and sex.
If something happens, scientists should be — and they are — asking questions like ‘how’ and ‘why’, and offering their versions of possible answers. What might they be?
Some evolutionary psychologists suggest that music originated as a way for males to impress and attract females. Others see its roots in the relationship between mother and child. In a third hypothesis, music was a social adhesive, helping to forge common identity in early human communities.
But some people are not convinced that there is any evolutionary purpose at all.
… [A] few leading evolutionary psychologists argue that music has no adaptive purpose at all, but simply manages, as the Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker has written, to “tickle the sensitive spots” in areas of the brain that evolved for other purposes. In his 1997 book “How the Mind Works,” Pinker dubbed music “auditory cheesecake” …
>asking questions like ‘how’ and ‘why’, and offering their versions of possible answers.
Carnatic music is entirely devotional. It appears that this angle has not been considered.
Abi,
Pl. also look at this http://human-nature.com/ep/reviews/ep03375380.html
and Robin Dunbar’s speculations about grooming etc. in “The Human Story” and the earlier “grooming, Gossip and Evolution of Language”. I think that at the moment these are mostly speculative.
[...] Just three weeks ago, we looked at a Boston Globe article on the evolutionary significance of music. In it we also noted Steven Pinker’s description of music as having no significance at all: music, according to him, is “auditory cheesecake.” [...]
[...] lasts throughout their lives. Some scientists believe that appreciation for music is something that developed during evolution as a way to create and maintain communities. In addition, there is evidence that music stimulates [...]
[...] Brain on Music” in which he totally disagrees with Steven Pinker who refers to music as “auditory cheesecake” meaning that our appreciation of music is an enjoyable side effect of language development. When [...]